Ma's Literary Corner
AMERICAN GOSPEL: God, the Founding Fathers, and the Making of a Nation, by Jon Meacham
WARNING! If you're not a reader of non-fiction, you may as well skip this long post. Also, Ma is not a professional book reviewer and this is not a professionally written paper for someone's class, so Ma's rules apply in regards to citations, etc.
It is hoped that someday Ma might join the ranks of those knowledgeable persons who do all these things in the precise and correct way. (and if any of my college kids are reading this, just do what you're told in class...after all, no one is paying me, either in grades or specie, specious or no)
ALSO, I recognize that this is not the most organized of presentations and goes overly long, but I thought every quote here included to be both interesting and helpful in my understanding and appreciation of this book...
...which brings up the fact that this is mostly quotes. I don't feel compelled to analyze the "what" or "wherefore" behind each citation. That would require...well...thought and reasoning powers. No one's ever accused me of that, to date.
AND ANOTHER THING, any perceived agreement with the theme or ideas put forth in this book are my own, and are not to be confused with people whom I associate with (occasionally even my immediate family) who might have other viewpoints on the matter.
That said, Meacham makes a distinction between private and civil religion. The references the Founding fathers made in speeches and documents referred not to their personal religious convictions which they designed to incorporate into the new government's very structure and laws, but rather were a reflection of that historical time period, of which many people believed in God or a Supreme Being.
In early colonial days there had been attempts to organize along the lines of strict religious beliefs and adherence to those beliefs. (John Winthrop of the Puritans and his treatment of Anne Hutchinson are an example of living amidst a theocracy...)
Winthrop's sermon, A Model of Christian Charity has been quoted many times, or at least, one small part has been quoted...
(OHHH yeah. Gotta love that theocratic state)
(now here's an interesting tidbit, in reference to a treaty as the result of pirate attacks off the Barbary Coast in the 1790's)
(in reference to John Quincy Adams and his defense of the slaves who mutinied on the Amistad...)
(Kennedy, concerning the Wisconsin primary...)
(politicians are all alike....if only they listened to themselves, occasionally)
(concerning the ever controversial concept of The Separation of Church and State, Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas wrote,)
I very much appreciated the overall tone of this book and basically agree with the thrust of its message, so let the reproving of Ma begin...
Tweet
WARNING! If you're not a reader of non-fiction, you may as well skip this long post. Also, Ma is not a professional book reviewer and this is not a professionally written paper for someone's class, so Ma's rules apply in regards to citations, etc.
It is hoped that someday Ma might join the ranks of those knowledgeable persons who do all these things in the precise and correct way. (and if any of my college kids are reading this, just do what you're told in class...after all, no one is paying me, either in grades or specie, specious or no)
ALSO, I recognize that this is not the most organized of presentations and goes overly long, but I thought every quote here included to be both interesting and helpful in my understanding and appreciation of this book...
...which brings up the fact that this is mostly quotes. I don't feel compelled to analyze the "what" or "wherefore" behind each citation. That would require...well...thought and reasoning powers. No one's ever accused me of that, to date.
AND ANOTHER THING, any perceived agreement with the theme or ideas put forth in this book are my own, and are not to be confused with people whom I associate with (occasionally even my immediate family) who might have other viewpoints on the matter.
That said, Meacham makes a distinction between private and civil religion. The references the Founding fathers made in speeches and documents referred not to their personal religious convictions which they designed to incorporate into the new government's very structure and laws, but rather were a reflection of that historical time period, of which many people believed in God or a Supreme Being.
In early colonial days there had been attempts to organize along the lines of strict religious beliefs and adherence to those beliefs. (John Winthrop of the Puritans and his treatment of Anne Hutchinson are an example of living amidst a theocracy...)
Winthrop's sermon, A Model of Christian Charity has been quoted many times, or at least, one small part has been quoted...
"The allusion to the Sermon o the Mount--that we are 'a city upon a hill'-- is one of the most oft-cited images of the United States as a kind of Promised Land that the early New England settlers, playing the part of the ancient Israelites, reached after an exodus of peril and crisis. Winthrop's text is frequently used as a source of reassurance about our exceptional national destiny, yet we should not be so quick to think that an ancient phrase of his can help us smooth over the rougher passages of our history, or that telling ourselves we are a special people entitles the country or any element within it to impose its will on others under the cloak of divine sanction." (pg 47)
"A nation can feel called to a special role without descending into paranoia and moral dictatorship--a balancing act Americans have come to handle well, but which was not achieved in the New England of John Winthrop and William Bradford." (pg 48)
"Having fled European conformity, the Puritans sought conformity of their own. The irony was not lost on the Old World. 'Every party cries out for Liberty & toleration,' said the Lord Bishop of Salisbury, 'till they get to be uppermost, and then will allow none.' " (pg 48)
"Connecticut's Code of 1650 was a brutal one. 'If any man shall have or worship any God but the Lord God, he shall be put to death,' it said." (pg 53)
(OHHH yeah. Gotta love that theocratic state)
"The God of the Declaration does not choose nations or peoples to favor, or others to curse. Americans, Jefferson had written, simply wanted to 'assume among the powers of the earth the separate and equal stations [emphasis by Meacham] to which the laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them....' Jefferson was not claiming that America was particularly exalted; he was seeking, as he writes, a 'separate and equal station' among the family of nations.
The founding religion--at least in the Declaration-- was based more on a religion of reason than of revelation. But it was still religion." (pg 74)
(now here's an interesting tidbit, in reference to a treaty as the result of pirate attacks off the Barbary Coast in the 1790's)
A TREATY WITH ISLAM
" 'As the government of the United States of America is not in any sense founded on the Christian Religion;--as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion or tranquility of Musselmen,--and as the said States never have entered into any war or act of hostility against any Mehomitan nation, it is declared by the parties that no pretext arising from religious opinions shall ever produce an interruption of harmony existing between the two countries.' "(pg 103)
(in reference to John Quincy Adams and his defense of the slaves who mutinied on the Amistad...)
" 'The world, the flesh, and all the devils in hell are arrayed against any man, who now, in this North-American Union, shall dare to join the standard of Almighty God, to put down the African slave-trade, and what can I, upon the verge of my seventy-fourth birthday, with a shaking hand, a darkening eye, a drowsy brain, and with all my faculties dropping fro me, one by one, as the teeth are dropping from my head, what can I do for the cause of God and man"
? for the progress of human emancipation? for the suppression of the African slave-trade Yet my conscience presses me on--let me but die upon the breach.'
Adams was taking his stand not on some narrow biblical ground, nor had he tried to use religion to defend what so many believed to be morally indefensible. As he said in his diary, he believed the 'African slave-trade' wrong--contrary to the 'cause of God and man.' It was a view taken after a lifetime of service to the nation and contemplation of philosophy, poetry, theology, and politics--the view of a man who, as the shadows lengthened, not only felt but thought that the right thing to do, however unpopular, would win him treasure in heaven if not on earth. Adams represented a particular breed of believer, one who takes solace in scripture but does not necessarily think the Bible is the only field of battle in life's wars.'"(pg 126, 127)
(Kennedy, concerning the Wisconsin primary...)
" 'I think the voters of Wisconsin objected to being categorized simply as either Catholics or Protestants...I think they objected to being accosted by reporters outside of political meetings and asked one question only--their religion--not their occupation or education or philosophy or income, only their religion.' A student of history and a lover of politics, Kennedy was astute about the electorate. 'For voters are more than Catholics, Protestants, or Jews,' he said. 'They make up their minds for many diverse reasons, good and bad. To submit the candidates tyo a religious test is unfair enough--to apply it to the voters themselves is divisive, degrading, and wholly unwarranted.' Tough, smart words, putting the press on notice while his campaign--like all campaigns--strategized and maneuvered, thinking of blocs of voters." (pg 183)
(politicians are all alike....if only they listened to themselves, occasionally)
THE TYRANNY OF THE PRESENT
"A grasp of history is essential for Americans of the center who struggle to decide how much weight to assign a religious consideration in a public mater. To fail to consult the past consigns us to what might be called the tyranny of the present--the mistaken idea that the crises of our own time are unprecedented and that we have to solve them without experience to guide us. Subject to such a tyranny, we are more likely to take a narrow or simplistic view, or to let our passions get the better of our reason. If we know, however, how those who came before us found the ways and means to surmount the difficulties of their age, we stand a far better chance of acting in the moment with perspective and measured judgment. Light can neither enter into nor emanate from a closed mind.
The intensity with which the religious right attempts to conscript the Founders into their cause indicates the importance the movement ascribes to historical benediction by association with the origins of the Republic. If Falwell and his seventy performers, (refers to a group of musicians he took on tour in 1976) or Tim LaHaye in his 'Faith of Our Founding Fathers,' can convince enough people that America was a Christian nation that has lost its way, the more legitimate their efforts in the political arena seem.
The problem with their reading of history is that it is wrong. There is no doubt, as we have seen, that the Founders lived in a consciously bequeathed a culture shaped and sustained by public religion, one that was not Christian or Jewish or Muslim or Buddhist but was simply transcendent, with reverence for the 'Creator' and for 'Nature's God.'
To hope, as some secularists do, that faith will one day withdraw from the public sphere, if only this presidential candidate or that Supreme Court nominee comes to power, is futile. Humankind could not leave off being religious even it if tried. The impulse is intrinsic. 'We and God have business with each other;' and in opening ourselves to his influence our deepest destiny is fulfilled,' William James told his scholarly audience in Edinburgh. 'The universe...takes a turn genuinely for the worse or for the better in proportion as each one of us fulfills or evades God's demands.' To James, 'the instinctive belief of mankind' is that 'God is real since he produces real effects.'" (pg 232, 233)
"The Republic is not a church, but it is a Republic filled with churches. Let the religious speak but encourage them not to shout; let them argue, but encourage them not to brawl. The system the Founders built allows for religious considerations to play a role in politics in the same measure--no greater, no smaller--as any other consideration, whether geographical, economic, or cultural." (pg 244)
(concerning the ever controversial concept of The Separation of Church and State, Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas wrote,)
" 'There cannot be the slightest doubt that the First Amendment reflects the philosophy that Church and State should be separated...The First Amendment, however, does not say that, in every and all respects there shall be a separation fo Church and State. Rather, it studiously defines the manner, the specific ways, in which there shall be no concert or union or dependency one on the other. That is the common sense of the matter. Otherwise the state and religion would be aliens to each other--hostile, suspicious, and even unfriendly. Churches could not be required to pay even property taxes. Municipalities would not be permitted to render police or fire protection to religious groups. Policemen who helped parishioners into their places of worship would violate the Constitution. Prayers in our legislative halls; the appeals to the Almighty in the message of the Chief Executive; the proclamations making Thanksgiving Day a holiday; 'so help me God' in our courtroom oaths--these and all other references to the Almighty that run through our laws, our public rituals, our ceremonies would be flouting the First Amendment. A fastidious atheist or agnostic could even object to the supplication with which the Court opens each session: 'God save the United States and this Honorable Court.' " (pg 239, 240)
"Madison saw all this coming, 'I must admit...,' he wrote, 'that it may not be easy in every possible case to trace the line of separation between the rights of religion and the Civil authority with such distinctness as to avoid collisions & doubts on unessential points.' And so the experiment goes on." (pg 241)
I very much appreciated the overall tone of this book and basically agree with the thrust of its message, so let the reproving of Ma begin...
Tweet

The Progeny
2 Comments:
You'll get no reproving from me. I have not read Meacham's work, but it seems to be on the right track.
Most of the Founders were children of the Enlightenment. As a result, virtually all of them were monotheists of some sort, many believed Jesus was a great moral teacher, and some liked to use Christian terminology to a certain extent -- but very few (at least of the main figures) were what today's evangelicals would recognize as Christians.
I'll quote a few suggestive passages from Thomas Jefferson (from my handy copy of his Life and Selected Writings, ed. Koch and Peden):
"I am a Christian, in the only sense in which [Jesus] wished any one to be; sincerely attached to his doctrines, in preference to all others; ascribing to himself every human excellence; and believing he never claimed any other." (Letter to Benjamin Rush, 21 April 1803, emphasis in original)
"Abstracting what was really [Jesus' teaching] from the rubbish in which it is buried, easily distinguished by its lustre from the dross of His biographers, and as separable from that as the diamond is from the dunghill, we have the outlines of a system of the most sublime morality which has ever fallen from the lips of man; outlines which it is lamentable He did not live to fill up." (Letter to William Short, 31 October 1819)
"Nor was the unity of the Supreme Being ousted from the Christian creed by the force of reason, but by the sword of civil government, wielded at the will of the fanatic Athanasius. The hocus-pocus phantasm of a God like another Cerberus, with one body and three heads, had its birth and growth in the blood of thousands and thousands of martyrs. [... but] I confidently expect that the present generation will see Unitarianism become the general religion of the United States." (Letter to James Smith, 8 December 1822)
Of course, Jefferson was not the only Founder. But I am convinced that he was not at all unusual. Certainly John Adams and Benjamin Franklin had similar ideas. Several others tended not to talk about their beliefs -- even the garrulous Jefferson was afraid of having his beliefs used against him in public -- but seem to have been similarly unorthodox.
Thank you for your thoughts and contributive quotes. I knew that if anyone had the stamina to read through this unordered and nonacademicness it might be yourself.
Post a Comment
<< Home