What Are They Afraid Of?
How interesting that the espousal of academic freedom only applies to certain subjects.
Dare to question Darwinism and one might kiss their career goodbye.
In his documentary, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, Ben Stein explores a few halls of academia, talks with scientists of differing ilks of origins, and raises some interesting questions.
Here's a 7:41 minute movie trailer:
Loren and I want to see this one with our whole family. Whether it will be in a theater or after it comes out on DVD, I don't know....but we definitely want to see it.
Click here if you wish to learn more or find a theater near you where it is showing.
Tweet
Dare to question Darwinism and one might kiss their career goodbye.
In his documentary, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, Ben Stein explores a few halls of academia, talks with scientists of differing ilks of origins, and raises some interesting questions.
Here's a 7:41 minute movie trailer:
Loren and I want to see this one with our whole family. Whether it will be in a theater or after it comes out on DVD, I don't know....but we definitely want to see it.
Click here if you wish to learn more or find a theater near you where it is showing.
Tweet

The Progeny
6 Comments:
This was worth the time. We made a family outing of it.
Deb
Don't do it. Expelled is bad news; definitely not a critical argument that can really be taken seriously. It's basically the equivalent of a Michael Moore documentary, and I think it's doing far more harm than good for its cause. At the very least, it's a textbook example of how not to conduct a rational discussion, which is precisely the opposite of what you'd want (or expect) from such a thing.
Check out my review, Sharpton's review, Peter Chattaway's review for Canadian Christianity, and some additional comments on his blog. Finally, a statement from the scholars at Reasons to Believe.
Key quote: "In Reasons To Believe's interaction with professional scientists, scientific institutions, universities, and publishers of scientific journals we have encountered no significant evidence of censorship, blackballing, or disrespect. As we have persisted in publicly presenting our testable creation model in the context of the scientific method, we have witnessed an increasing openness on the part of unbelieving scientists to offer their honest and respectful critique.
"Our main concern about Expelled is that it paints a distorted picture. It certainly doesn't match our experience. Sadly, it may do more to alienate than to engage the scientific community, and that can only harm our mission."
But Wheeler, you don't seriously expect me to not go just because you said, "Don't do it," do you?
:-D
I read all of the reviews you listed and I'd still like to see it for myself and make my own judgment.
No human has a complete handle on TRUTH...even those who have extensive experience in genres of film and literature.
I do appreciate your input and will keep it in mind when I view the movie/documentary/whatever-it-is.
Certainly not, certainly not. My opening phrase was purely rhetorical. After all, I went to see it even though I had reason to suspect what the result would be.
I just felt it was worth pointing out to anyone that was thinking of going to the movie expecting information on Darwinism, Intelligent Design, academic freedom, etc., Expelled either misunderstands or just willfully misrepresents all of these issues in a big way, and that may not be immediately apparent from simply watching the movie. It is, overall, reasonably entertaining (for anyone who isn't simply offended), but it is exactly the opposite of educational.
Quite so. Your post, ma'am, is very much an endorsement, even though you have not (unless I misunderstand you) seen the film yet. Having actually seen the movie, Jared is fully qualified to offer an anti-endorsement, no?
That doesn't mean that he's trying to suppress anything. But he might -- and this is just my guess -- be warning you about widely shared concerns about the film you have been promoting.
I have not seen the film, yet. But Loren and I did listen to part of the Glenn Beck radio program--on one of the long trips up to Rochester--wherein Ben Stein was interviewed, and it all sounded most interesting.
(by the way, the only time I listen to talk radio is when I'm stuck in a vehicle for a long trip. By myself, it's music, music, music...)
We had also heard about the film from Loren's brother who has been keeping abreast of Intelligent Design issues.
I guess one of the intriguing things about the whole deal is that one doesn't often find this topic broached in a main stream media venue, so while I may have indeed been endorsing it without having seen it, perhaps what I am really endorsing is the opportunity for something like this to be heard.
Having said that, I do hope it gives a good account of itself.
Ultimately though, it is a vehicle by which primarily one man, Ben Stein (and his producers, etc), is/are putting forth his/their views.
And I ultimately hope that the cause of reason and truth regarding this issue would not be squelched.
Post a Comment
<< Home